Rules, and their consequences

In principle, the campaign started by Nick Clegg to find out which laws, rules and regulations people want to abolish is music to the ears of those in tune with Human Politics, the guiding principle of which is that human relationships should be governed by mutual respect and understanding rather than artificial or arbitrary rules.

For that principle to find expression, space needs to be created in which relationships may grow and flourish. This space is currently occupied by a colossal body of state-directed regulation from which the realities of human motivation have been banished. There is a difference between conforming and behaving truly well, and it is difficult to do both at the same time. If people are to behave well they must do so of their own volition, in which case the obligation to conform must first be removed.

The campaign’s weakness, however, is that it does not set out to question the principle of rule-making, or even its purpose. The contract between people and government, whereby the government controls a large chunk of the things that people want and need, and people have to behave in a certain way in order to access or make use of them, is so well established that the language with which to challenge it is close to being lost. As a consequence there is something pleading, almost obsequious, about many of the postings on the Your Freedom website. People write that they accept that some or other regulation is needed but would respectfully suggest this or that slight modification, because it would suit them. People seem to want regulation of other people, but wish not to be inconvenienced themselves by the same regulation. In effect, they trust nobody but expect to be trusted.

Such an approach can at best bring only a temporary slowing of the tendency towards an ever more regulated society. It is always easier to articulate a reason for a rule than to explain why it isn’t needed. Abolishing rules, therefore, is not the most effective way of changing the consciousness in relation to them and could, indeed, have the opposite effect. Pruning reinvigorates the tree. Get rid of one rule and you may soon find two new ones have taken its place. The only effective way to get rid of the tree completely is to dig up its root.

What is the root of rules and regulations? The answer is enforcement, which is a slightly less direct way of saying punishment. The root of a parking infraction is the fine. Without the fine, the infraction itself is lifeless. From the point of view of the driver, it is the fine that makes the infraction, not the rule itself. Breaking a rule without consequences suggests that the rule was not really a rule at all.

This is the mindset of enforcement: you broke the rule or you didn’t; you got caught and punished or you didn’t. It was getting caught that made the offence real. Your actual behaviour is neither here nor there. The first rule of a rule-based system, therefore, is don’t get caught. Suppose, however, that instead of looking at the narrow rule-breaking your behaviour was judged in the round? It may be harder work to relate to people with reference to their circumstances and intentions, but it is infinitely more worthwhile. It validates the complexities of human behaviour and creates the conditions for self-responsibility. Now, knowing in yourself what you did or did not do is what matters, and getting caught or otherwise is beside the point. People who take responsibility for their own actions will always get caught, because they catch themselves.

So if the deputy prime minister really wants to change the relationship between the citizen and the state he should look not at the rules themselves, but at the authority that lies behind them. The power of the state to enforce its diktat is a poor shadow of the power of the human will to govern itself, but this latter power can only operate in a state of freedom. That freedom is innate; it is not in the gift or grant of anyone, but it can be obscured by the hissing static of state interference and a truly courageous government would act to turn that static off.

Like the parents of a pair of squabbling teenagers the government should stop pretending that it is in control of people’s lives. People need to learn to live with one another out of their own will, and not because they are made to. But they are not likely to start until a government finds the courage to dispense with the crude system of sticks and carrots called enforcement and throws the problem back at people, saying “Grow up and sort it out for yourselves!”