Blog index, 2003-04

Here is a list of blog posts from the 2003 – 2004 series, which appeared originally on the Mindhenge website.

For later blogs, click here.

To narrow the range, use the search box or select one of the tags attached to each post.

Please note that the posts are republished her with their original date and embedded links. Some of these links, particularly in the older posts, are likely to be broken.

  • Knowing when to quit
    In 1997 the British people wanted a new politics, but the failed gestures of the intervening seven years have brought them back to precisely the disillusioned state from which they sought to escape at that time.
  • Representative government
    Society is complicated, and a legislature split between two dominant parties presents a bogus polarity in which those complications are unrepresented.
  • The limits of nation-building
    Whether a society can be built in Iraq that works both for the Iraqis and the U.S. must be doubtful, to put it mildly. One side or other is likely to be disappointed.
  • Squeezing the nation
    Mr Blunkett’s ill-judged decision to try to bounce Humberside Police Authority into suspending their chief constable is a symptom of a deeper malaise at the national tier of government.
  • Race to the bottom
    Saying “no” is not enough. When people start to question UKIP’s alternative they will find the answers to be pretty thin.
  • Calling “time” on prohibition
    John Reid’s remarks about smoking are a timely reminder that behavioural change depends upon providing attractive alternatives. Mere enforcement is not enough.
  • United we stand…
    Public attitudes are so poisoned that for British governments there can be no such thing as a successful policy on Europe.
  • The cherry on the stick
    A “calorie tax” is not coercive; it does not force people into certain choices. Rather, it gives self-interest an opportunity that social and economic pressures might otherwise deny.
  • With all due respect
    Al Qaida and Fathers 4 Justice may be a very far cry indeed from one another, but they occupy, nonetheless, two places in a continuum of political failure.
  • Clever, modest and misunderstood
    The development of the European Union has been a quiet, understated exercise in compromise which Britons might be expected to appreciate if they were permitted the political head space to reflect upon it.
  • Inconsequential opinions
    David Blunkett and Tony Blair think that identity cards are a good thing. And opinion pollsters tells us that maybe 80 per cent of adult Britons think so too. But is this good enough reason for a policy for which the practical benefits seem remarkably thin?
  • Not insular, but everywhere
    In agreeing to hold a referendum on Europe, Tony Blair has set himself the ambitious task of re-writing powerful myths about the British and their neighbours.
  • The old realities of history
    The endorsement by George Bush of Ariel Sharon’s self-serving plan to withdraw from the Gaza Strip while retaining substantial sections of the West Bank is pure politics and will have little if any influence on whatever settlement is eventually reached in that region.
  • Fanatically opposed to fanatics
    The coalition is just as inflexible as its opponents about the political outcome it is willing to allow in Iraq. But, if it wants peace, it is going to have to learn to let go.
  • Tell it like it is
    The government’s immigration policy is collapsing because it is trying to do one thing while saying another.
  • Constitutional crumble
    A bizarre confrontation between the Commons and the Lords over an obscure bill has wide implications for the way that legislation is reviewed. How much longer can Britain’s creaking constitution cope with a government so determined to get its way?
  • The power to provoke
    The Spanish people were always against the war in Iraq, and they still are, but their consistency has not stopped U.S. Republican Congressman Dennis Hastert accusing them of appeasing terrorists. He could not be more wrong.
  • The roots of terrorism
    The outcome of the Spanish election is not a victory for the terrorists, but a recognition that international terrorism is a symptom of a global political and social malaise that the rich, western world has the primary responsibility to address.
  • The administration of justice
    Lord Woolf was right, last week, in his speech in Cambridge, to link the government’s constitutional reform plans to the iniquitous clause 11 of the Asylum and Immigration Bill now going through parliament. If they pass un-amended the reform plans can only encourage an authoritarian tendency in the government that the asylum bill plainly reveals.
  • Test tube politics
    The government wants a national standard for the availability of medical interventions such as IVF, but it also wants local people to have a greater say in the provision of services in their area. This paradox will not resolve itself for so long as national politics remains the only show in town.
  • (no title)
    The U.S. is splashing out out on an expensive economic recovery in an election year. Eurozone growth may be slower, but its longer term prospects look a better bet. Britain, as usual, is torn both ways.
  • Selling out the brand
    The failure of the Prime Minister to support his own government’s policy on immigration by workers from E.U. accession countries illustrates the credibility gap he has opened up with an increasingly unconvinced electorate. Pandering to the right wing press on the issue will not paper over the cracks.
  • Ways of dying
    The news impact of violent or multiple killings drowns out the muffled toll of persistent premature death caused by illness and poverty. David Blunkett’s proposals for a reduced burden of criminal proof in cases of terrorism is symptomatic of a tendency to prioritise the immediate and dramatic over long term, less sensational needs.
  • A reckless report
    Lord Hutton has treated the government with a care that he has not extended to the BBC. But, whereas prime ministers come and go, the BBC has a fixed place in the firmament, and any long term damage inflicted upon it by his lordship’s failure of understanding will have consequences for us all.
  • Metaphorical jig-saw puzzles
    The government will get nowhere if it continues to make war against young people. Occupation, not punishment, is what they need.
  • Paying the piper
    The debate about the funding of local government will fail to make progress until politicians face up to the reality of who’s calling the tune.
  • Sensible behaviour
    When laws are broken by responsible people in their millions, enforcement is not the answer. It’s time for the government to look for a more constructive approach.
  • The limits of self-reliance
    A simple, fair, transparent tax system that undertakes to provide everybody with specified services of a specified quality. Is that really too much to ask?
  • Finding reverse gear
    At the onset of hubris, can schadenfreude be far behind? But it’s not too late for Tony Blair to acknowledge that his Labour critics have a point of view, too.
  • The nasty government?
    Tory leader Michael Howard sounded more liberal than the government on asylum last week. So perhaps it’s time to acknowledge that the public attitudes on this issue are more complicated than they look.
  • Give, not take
    The idea that American self-interest is everybody else’s interest may make for an attractive moral certainty but it won’t solve the world’s problems or even make U.S. interests more secure.
  • The wide Atlantic
    British government ideas for a single U.S.-E.U. market reflect a vision of shared interests and values that is supported neither by history not by contemporary reality.
  • Words matter
    The term “anti-Semitism” has a uniquely powerful association that is both useful and dangerous for those who support the policy of the Israeli government.
  • Country before party?
    Michael Howard is promising a new kind of politics, without “narrow partisan opportunism”. The British public may be ready for this, but is Mr Howard? Really?
  • Making asylum work
    Asylum seekers and economic migrants can be an asset as well as a cost. Letting them work while their cases are considered is useful for society and saves money, too.
  • A classic problem-solving error
    Civil society is complicated and messy. Giving everyone a piece of plastic with a number on it will not make it less so.
  • A party adrift
    The Tory party lacks credibility because it can’t agree what sort of credibility it wants. Until it does, all its handsome new policy initiatives will be beside the point.
  • Plus ça change…
    Tony Blair’s big speech lacked purposeful ideas about where to take his government. For Labour, he seemed to say, the best it can hope to do is keep the Tories at bay.
  • The admirable Mr Dingemans
    A comparison of the two parts of the Hutton Enquiry hearings, now more-or-less concluded, reveals a weakness that goes to the heart of British political and judicial structures.
  • Inevitability postponed
    The emergence of a new identity among the less developed countries at Cancun sends a signal that the introspective mega-economies of the West will ignore at their peril.
  • Telling truth to power
    When everybody around the prime minister knows what he wants to hear, objectivity is the first casualty.
  • Crime and punishment
    When the degree of suffering inflicted on the guilty is the measure of society’s moral self-affirmation, something, somewhere, has gone badly wrong.
  • The “when?” of destiny
    Some things are bound to happen, one day, but it needn’t be tomorrow. If future generations are to thank them, political leaders need to know when to embrace destiny and when to fight it with a policy of “inevitability postponed”.
  • Feeling, not thinking
    The September dossier on WMD was not so much a balanced judgement as the case for the prosecution. Where in Downing Street were the people making the case for the other side?
  • Neither one thing nor the other
    A levels have lost their way because, with the democratisation of university education, people can’t agree what the exam is for. The problem comes from trying to test achievement and potential at the same time.
  • Pointless misery
    By toughening up on asylum-seekers, the government is turning complicated human issues into a numbers game that it cannot win. Spare a thought for the innocent victims caught in the fall out. The expulsion of Kurdish asylum-seeker Yurdigal Ay and her four children from this country and their return to Germany on the grounds that they asylum application had already been processed (and rejected) there, has given rise, as usual, to a fair amount of humane-thinking protest, not least in Scotland. The family settled there four years ago; a year ago Mr Ay returned to Germany,… Read more: Pointless misery
  • Meaning, not words
    Language is democratic because only the listener or reader decides what it means. When a writer or speaker attempts to impose their message, they only succeed in deluding themselves.
  • The limits of power
    Power lies in the ability to get things right. A decision is not right because the decision-maker is powerful, but because the process of reaching it has been effective. That requires openness to the truth, not managed information.
  • Getting things right
    Information is only as good as the assessment that is made of it, but an assessment does not itself make the information true. No amount of power can make it true, either.
  • Not learning from history
    True power consists not in the exercise of force but in the ability to bring about the desired outcome. It is always easier to start something than to control where it goes.
  • Encouraging inter-dependence
    Government proposals for gay marriage are good policy, and good politics, too. But encouraging mutual support and dependence could be much more widely extended, to the advantage of society as a whole.
  • Letting the regulator take the strain
    The government is letting commercial public service providers budget for a profit while its own regulator is doing all the sums that matter. So why shouldn’t a state-owned contractor pitch for the work?
  • The devalued vote
    The connection between elections and reality was always tenuous, but never more so than it is today. Non-voters are not nihilists, but honest citizens increasingly unwilling to collude in a deception.
  • Direction of travel
    Transport secretary Alastair Darling is thinking the unthinkable on roads. Apparently, that means paying for them. But road-pricing alone won’t end congestion – it will just make people even more fed up when they find themselves paying to be stuck in a jam.
  • Bearing bad news
    If peace is to come in the Israel-Palestine conflict the Israelis are going to have to keep on giving, and only the Americans can make them. Bush had better be up for it, because it’s a stance that only a right-wing administration can hope to sustain.
  • Keeping things complicated
    Good decision-making is a process of questioning, and that involves listening carefully to the answers that you least expect.
  • What do we want? We want…er…
    Hands up anybody who knows what drugs policy in Britain is designed to achieve. In an area of a thousand policy objectives and targets, what’s the big picture?
  • Addressing the issue
    Suicide bombers have big commitment to their cause. That’s why they do it. Their terrorists acts do not invalidate the cause, they merely push it up the agenda. That’s why, when the cause is popular, terrorism often works.
  • Facts matter
    When it comes to votes, public perception matters more than statistical reality. This makes politicians say (and do) foolish things. In the end we all pay for it.
  • Policy baggage
    The results of the local elections in England raise questions for all three main parties. But really it all comes down to one big question: What is a political party for?
  • Jaw, jaw in Europe
    When Germany, France, Belgium and Luxembourg sat down last week to talk about European defence co-operation, their efforts received a mixed reception. Some people were irritated, some derisive, some embarrassed, some sceptical and some, doubtless, quietly pleased.
  • Go with the flow
    Budget day offers a reminder of how governments try to influence the way that people behave. But the effect is not always predictable and certainly not always what the government intends.
  • What’s the plan?
    It must, as we noted last week, be galling for Tony Blair that his humanitarian agenda for war in Iraq has no justification in international law. Fortunately, provided it works for the Iraqis, that won’t matter. But will it work? And how to make it?
  • The logic of war
    When decision-makers act instinctively, for a jumble of reasons, it may be possible to work backwards from the decision to uncover the true objective. Might this process shed light on the war in Iraq?