Lord Hutton has treated the government with a care that he has not extended to the BBC. But, whereas prime ministers come and go, the BBC has a fixed place in the firmament, and any long term damage inflicted upon it by his lordship’s failure of understanding will have consequences for us all.
The Hutton report reveals in the mind of its author a set of values rooted somewhere in a distant part of the twentieth century. According to those values, the government and its members and agents are solid citizens striving earnestly and tirelessly for the public good. To impugn their motives or honesty is an act of subversion that ought, as a matter of principle, to be deplored. People in positions of responsibility who fail to prevent such subversion are doubly culpable – both vicariously for the act itself and directly for their own failure to prevent it.
There is something to be said for this point of view. Government in the high-minded British tradition is a great and valued social asset. You do not need to look as far as the world’s dodgiest regimes to see how blessed the U.K is with its political institutions. You only need to look as far as Italy or the United States, where constitutional proprieties have been trampled on in ways that would still, one hopes, cause outrage were they to be attempted in Great Britain.
By upholding the position of the government, therefore, Lord Hutton appears to be defending the legitimate organs of the state. From his point of view the accusations that matter are those that lie against the government, and he dismisses these without effort, possibly because he is applying a strict, “beyond reasonable doubt” standard of proof. And because he finds for the government on these points, it follows in his lawyerly mind that he finds against the other main protagonist. If the government was right, the BBC must be wrong, and it is criticised accordingly in the report.
The inability of senior members of the judiciary to comprehend that prominent members of the political establishment can do wrong has a long history. One is reminded of Peter Cook’s memorable parody of the judge in the Jeremy Thorpe trial, which concluded with the line “The jury will now retire to consider its verdict of not guilty.” Hutton’s own judgement almost defies parody because it is so one-sided as to parody itself.
History will, nonetheless, be grateful to his lordship for the thoroughness of his process. The published evidence and transcripts reveal much about the internal workings of government that had previously only been surmised, and the mismatch between the evidence before the enquiry and its findings is something that history will rapidly correct. The judge’s reputation will suffer as a consequence, and in that sense he has done himself few favours with the openness of his process. But the chief weakness of his report lies in his failure to understand how the body politic of Great Britain has evolved from the model with which he clearly feels most comfortable.
That traditional model, of the government as “something other” – a magisterial, elevated entity forming the superior part of a simple dualism of government and governed – has been superseded by a complex network of relationships connecting many institutions, bodies and individuals. This process was given a tremendous boost by the Thatcherite drive for privatisation, quango-isation and the general slimming down of central government. The development of the power of the E.U., of devolved Welsh and Scottish institutions, and the present government’s oft-stated desire to localise control of the delivery of services, have all contributed to its continuation. Political authority is all over the place these days and the national government is only one, albeit large, piece in the jig-saw.
Nor is the national government magisterial in its modus operandi. Lord Hutton’s enquiry revealed, if nothing else, the office of the prime minister as a group of grown up and particularly brainy schoolboys. They lacked gravitas, they lacked moral integrity and they lacked a mature political perspective as they cobbled together the infamous dossier. When finding it was weak, instead of asking themselves why it was weak they asked only how they could make it stronger. When faced with the allegations contained in the report of Andrew Gilligan on the Today programme they used the episode to stoke a feud with the BBC, a feud driven entirely by issues of presentation that completely ignored the substantial reality that underpinned Andrew Gilligan’s account.
Modern politics is the art of what an increasingly sophisticated, informed and connected society is willing to accept. It is a political marketplace in which, amongst an ever growing number of institutions, the press, the internet and the broadcast media play an important part. The rôle played by the BBC is an enormous one – by far the largest deliverer of public information in Great Britain and the forum for a substantial chunk of its political debate. The BBC will still be there, and still performing this central function, long after most of the government actors in this whole sorry saga are relegated to the footnotes of history.
Because of this, the duty of care that Lord Hutton extended to the government should also have been extended to the BBC. Accusations were laid against the BBC that Lord Hutton did not choose to investigate except in the narrowest sense. The fact that the BBC’s reporting in relation to the preparation of the disputed dossier was substantially accurate, and the poor light that this fact shed upon the government, was something to which he did not draw attention. If the BBC suffers long term damage as a result of this failure of balance, the consequences for the health of the British body politic will arguably be greater that if a prime minister had been forced to resign.
A damaged government can be replaced, prime ministers come and go, and the sins of the predecessor are rarely visited with any force upon the successor. A damaged BBC is altogether a more serious proposition. Lord Hutton has been reckless in his criticism, partly through a failure to understand the symbiotic relationship between government and media and partly through his refusal to consider whether the underlying thrust of the BBC’s reporting on the WMD dossier was essentially true. Now the damage has been done and replacing the men at the helm will not automatically restore the corporation’s credibility.
Hutton has treated the unfortunate David Kelly with a similar lack of care. Although beyond his power to restore him to life, he was unwilling, even, to restore his reputation by acknowledging the validity of the concerns that he expressed in his conversations with Susan Watts and Andrew Gilligan. For the government as for Lord Hutton, Dr Kelly was essentially a pawn – a mere functionary who could not be allowed to impede the government’s determined course of action. But the reality of politics is that there are no functionaries now. We are all, in our separate ways, politicians, with a legitimate claim upon the process of government to which we submit. Dr Kelly’s rights in the matter, as the BBC’s, were no less that the government’s own, and it ill-became Lord Hutton to neglect them.
The consequence, incidentally, has been the second-worst outcome for Tony Blair; better only than a finding of dishonesty against the prime minister. For whereas a more even report, indicating possible failures of intelligence and an inappropriate enthusiasm on the part of the government to make more than they should have done of the intelligence they had, might have passed muster as the inquiry into the cause of the war that everybody has been looking for, the acquittal of the government on every conceivable charge that Hutton drew within his remit means that the question of why Britain went to war remains wide open. No line can now be drawn until this matter is investigated. The prime minister can put it off until the Iraq Survey Group finally reports in the summer, but the consequence is that the inquiry, when it comes, will drag on into an election year, with the BBC in particular hanging onto every word.
