Riot and pillage

Rioting and looting go hand in hand, and always have done. To attempt to distinguish motivation between the two is unhelpful. As a package they represent an attack upon the status quo, both political and economic. Politics and economics are closely intertwined; as purveyors of the consumer goods upon which the economy depends, shops are an obvious and available target, and it is not likely in the heat of the moment that attackers will distinguish between struggling local retailers and the multiple chains.

This helps to explain something that has been a surprise to a few: why some of the people appearing in court are well-educated and apparently in “good” jobs. Educated people, especially those working in social care or education itself, are more highly politicised than most and more likely to be active in protest situations. That they failed to spot (or spotted too late) the point at which protest flipped over into criminality, does not condone their behaviour, but it does contextualise it. When violence such as we have seen recently breaks out across the country there is a message in there somewhere for the government, if only they can hear it.

The message itself is a complicated one, and repays deconstruction. Inequality is a central thread; the inequality that sees black teenagers disproportionately targeted by police, as well as the inequality that encourages the rich to get richer while middle incomes stagnate and low incomes decline. But the problems of disadvantage and marginalisation are compounded by issues of self-responsibility. Everybody decries the irresponsibility implicit in the violence, and yet parents find they are not empowered to exercise responsibility for their rebellious children and young adults are not empowered to take responsibility for their own lives.

Responsibility requires opportunity and means. To play a responsible role in society you have to have a role in society, a role that is sustainable and allows you to progress. Parents who lack the means or circumstances to point their growing or grown-up children towards a purposeful life cannot be blamed when destructive behaviour fills the vacuum thus created. The dirty secret of inequality is that it distinguishes not the idle rich from the toiling poor, but the people for whose benefit society is constructed from those for whom it is not. If you are young, black and living in north London, society does not habitually give you the breaks that might make you feel that you belong. Nor do you have to be marginalised to be dispossessed; those care workers and teaching assistants who appeared in court the other day are paid too little to imagine that they will ever own a home.

So, responsibility is a two way street. People have forsaken responsibility for society because society has not afforded them the means to participate. The culture of entitlement against which it is fashionable to rail is a poor substitute for the genuine opportunity that prefigures self-responsibility, but at present it is all that many young people know.