It may seem a curious thing for a political blogger to keep silent during a general election and its aftermath, but frankly I think it is the best course. Reactions to the moment become so quickly out-dated that unless, like Churchill, one is nourished by a diet of eaten words it is better to sit back and let events unfold.
Now they have unfolded, it looks very much as if the electorate’s desire for something – anything – different has been answered, and if not by a big spike in support for the Liberal Democrats then perhaps something almost better. No party emerged from the election feeling like a winner, which, if we are lucky, will mean a government more inclined to listen to the subtleties of the messages people send it and less inclined to lay down the law about how people behave. Early signs are promising, provided you are not a government bureaucrat facing threat of redundancy or have no faith in the wisdom of people to make good decisions for themselves.
In the novel political atmosphere that the coalition has created, the events leading to the resignation of leading Liberal Democrat and newly appointed Chief Secretary to the Treasury David Laws have left commentators wondering which way to jump. The amount and context of Mr Laws’s expenses claims for accommodation in London were not themselves unreasonable. There were a number of ways in which he could have claimed the money without raising any questions of probity. These methods would, however, have required him making public this relationship with the person to whom he was paying his rent. That in choosing to conceal his gay relationship he fell foul of a rule that forbids claiming rent paid to a partner is either a personal tragedy deserving of sympathy or an expenses rip-off by a wealthy former banker. Take your pick from the comments attached to this comment piece in a liberal newspaper.
That is the trouble with rules: every rule designed to govern people’s behaviour will eventually be made to look ridiculous by a set of circumstance that the rule-makers had not foreseen. Mr Laws appears to have broken a rule but not, in fact, to have overstated his expenses. A number of his colleagues in parliament successfully overstated their expenses without apparently breaking any rules (because the rules encouraged them to overstate their expenses). On the face of it, the moral ascendancy tends rather towards Mr Laws than these colleagues, but arguably both have fallen short in a moral conversation that could be characterised as “entitlement versus need”. Expenses of the sort paid to our parliamentarians are things they need to claim in order to do their job properly, not things they are entitled to claim because they do their job properly. These are clever folk, and ought to be able to tell the difference.
The tragedy is that the rules did not encourage them to apply their moral judgement, so now the impression has been gained that they don’t have any. Mr Laws, although he did, in fact, apply a personal moral judgement, was therefore probably right to assume that public opinion would think the worst about him, and duly fell on his sword. For the same reason, Members of Parliament and even ministers of the crown are now obliged to take their chances in second class railway carriages for what are often long journeys back to their constituencies, wasting valuable time during which they could be working on those constituents’ behalf. If this story is to be believed, ministers are even taking the train while the red boxes carrying their paperwork make the same journey “for security reasons” by chauffeur-driven car.
An overblown sense of entitlement is a common failing among people who work hard for the good of others, and find themselves poorly rewarded for their trouble. Arguably, Members of Parliament are, indeed, poorly paid for what they do, relative to other professions, but the reward they appear primarily to feel the lack of is the esteem of the public, a lack which can rapidly change into a much more serious emotional difficulty, which is a lack of self-esteem. I can almost hear the hollow laughter as I apply that phrase to our elected representatives, but consider how quick they were to condemn both themselves and others when the “expenses scandal” blew. The mea culpas made for good schadenfreude but the voices of the brave few who attempted to justify themselves with reference to the rules and accepted practice of the day struck me as far more authentic on a human level.
Mr Laws’s reasons for preferring private to public authenticity are not a matter for the judgement, still less the condemnation, of others. But his story is a reminder that behind every clock-tower, moat and duck-house lurks another individual human story, more banal, perhaps but no less real for the person caught up in it. The sums of money, relatively trivial in their totality, that made up the expenses scandal show that fraud is not the natural metier of our parliamentarians. If they were out to rip the public off they did not do it very well.
If the public are to renew their trust in politicians, the first step is for the politicians to renew their trust in themselves – to throw out the petty-fogging rules they have been lumbered with and prove that they can make sensible, moderate and prudent decisions about their own behaviour without being told how to do so. I’m more inclined to trust Mr Laws because he broke the rules for a good reason than I would trust someone who lacked the subtlety to make such fine moral judgements. The authentic voice is now a rare sound in politics; the political life of this country will never recover until such time as that voice is everywhere heard.
