After what seems like weeks of over-heated speculation and grotesquely uninformed commentary about Jon Venables, at last some words of wisdom from somebody who, even if they don’t know the details of the specific case, appears at least to have a humane and principled grasp of the issues underlying it.
Maggie Atkinson, the children’s commissioner for England, argues in an interview in today’s Times that the age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales should be raised to at least twelve, and that the two boys who were ten years old when they killed James Bulger should not have been processed through the criminal justice system.
The one hundred or more comments that accompany the Times article online are mostly (but by no means all) filled with predictable outrage, with most posters attributing to Dr Atkinson (and then disagreeing with) the view that children as young as ten do not know the difference between right and wrong. There is no evidence in the interview to suggest that she holds this opinion; all she is saying is that a criminal justice system designed for people with adult understanding is not an appropriate means of dealing with wrongdoing by children, however extreme.
What is particularly depressing is not the opinions of outraged posters on websites, who are as powerless as the rest of us to comprehend society’s ills and are perhaps fortunate that modern technology has provided such a public space for them to vent their frustration. No, what is depressing is that within hours of the interview appearing (on a Saturday) a Ministry of Justice spokesman had already dismissed Dr Atkinson’s proposal out of hand, saying:
“We believe that children aged 10 and over can differentiate between bad behaviour and serious wrongdoing. We do not intend to raise the age of criminal responsibility. It is not in the interests of justice, of victims, or the young people themselves, to prevent serious offending being challenged.”
Interestingly (although perhaps unsurprisingly in the weeks before a general election), the ministry makes the same mistake as the Times’ posters in addressing the age at which children can discriminate in their actions, rather than whether the criminal justice system is the right place to deal with those actions. The ministry emulates the attitudes of the posters in another important respect, too, in that it expresses its position as a matter of opinion (or belief, as they touchingly phrase it), rather than making reference to facts, research or any form of intellectual enquiry.
In fact the ministry must know perfectly well that there are many ways, quite possibly more effective, of challenging serious offending by children other than processing them through a system that they have absolutely no possibility of understanding or engaging with. So what we have here is a classic case of politicians and people feeding each other’s visceral opinions, creating a climate in which considered dissent is increasingly difficult. Is the vilification worth it? We will have to hope that Dr Atkinson, and the small number of Times readers willing to brave the wrath of the majority by agreeing with her, will continue to think so. Otherwise, the handcart beckons, it has “hell” written on its destination board and we are all about to get on board.
