According to reports by the BBC, the new Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority is to cost £6.6m in its first year, on top of the £1.5m that has been spend on recent investigations into parliamentary expenses. The new body is to employ about 80 staff.
Comparisons have been made between these sums and the £1.1m of expenses that MPs were required to pay back as the result of the enquiry. Some will see the exercise as a bad return on investment; others will say that it is the principle of the thing that matters, and it is worth upholding the principle at any cost.
I’m all for upholding principles, but it’s important to make sure that the principle is the most useful one to fit the circumstances. In a case like this, I think the principle of trust is a good place to start.
It has to be worrying that our MPs need 80 people to perform a task described on the authority’s website thus:
[to] provide rigorous scrutiny and review of the allowances scheme for Members of Parliament… and put in place a new independent system for the payment of salaries and allowances for MPs.
Allowing for 650 or so MPs, this works out at one person to check up on the expenses and remuneration of every eight of them, from which one can only conclude that the new body is not intending to trust MPs at all. Nor does it seem likely that MPs are willing to trust themselves. Whenever they make a claim they will want someone from the new authority to sign in blood to say that it is OK. The new regulators will be desperate not to get this wrong, so presumably will be crawling over all those receipts with a fine tooth comb.
The problems this will cause are entirely predictable. The authority will have to write rules, and the application of these rules will always give rise to areas of uncertainty. More and more time and energy will be spent in these grey areas and at some point someone is going to make a wrong call, and the press will be all over it. The old system, let’s remember, was based on rules. Many of those asked to make repayments could truthfully say that they were following these rules to the letter.
This difficulty is illustrated by the difference in approach of Sir Thomas Legg, who enquired into MPs expenses, and Sir Paul Kennedy, who heard the individual appeals against Sir Thomas’s judgements. Sir Thomas appears to have considered what was reasonable, whereas Sir Paul’s approach was necessarily more legalistic, and took greater account of the rules themselves. That is why Sir Paul reduced in several cases the sums that Sir Thomas thought ought to have been repaid.
Leaving aside specific cases, I much prefer Sir Thomas’s approach. He seems to be saying that grown up people who have taken it upon themselves to make laws for the rest of us should be able to work out for themselves what is or is not reasonable in relation to expenses, irrespective of what the rules say. The implication is that if we can’t trust them to do that, why on earth would we trust them at all.
Looked at in this way, all that is needed is a general principle, that expenses must relate to additional costs actually incurred. If society were willing to trust MPs to conform to this principle it would save itself a vast amount of money and effort. The quid pro quo, however, is that MPs are people, and people are people. Some will claim too much, others too little, and a few, a very few, will take the system for a ride. We need to learn to live with that, and be grateful for any small improvements that can be made along the way.
Trust is hard to make and easy to destroy, so the times when trust is breached are the times when we must cling most strongly to it, clean up the mess and keep on trusting. If everything is so regulated that nobody can just be trusted to do what is sensible, then life will become intolerable and we may as well resign ourselves into the hands of a police state.
We need to start to trust our parliamentarians, whether they deserve it or not, if only in the hope that they will start to learn to trust us.
