On holiday I’ve been reading the recently published Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely, whose website on the same subject can be found here. I was particularly struck by his comparison of the free and the market economies, and the experiments that show how people work harder and more willingly for free than they do when paid to perform the same task. By chance, Professor Ariely and his colleagues are blogging on the same subject this week.
The experiments show that when asked to perform a standardised task, those working for free do more work than those working for a good fee ($5 for five minutes work) and much better than those working for a poor fee (10 cents for five minutes). The conclusion drawn is that when a relationship is conducted according to “market” rules, people place the rules above the relationship and only work as hard as seems appropriate for the amount they are being paid. But when the relationship is a “open” one, freely entered entered into, people freely give of their best.
About the same time I was reading this article in The Independent, which reports a doubling in the amount on litter on Britain’s beaches over a 15 year period. Litter is only one of a number of social problems that appear to have multiplied in recent years, and yet, as we know, the British government has introduced an average of roughly one new punishable offence for each day it has been in office in the last twelve years or so, so there has been no shortage of new rules to try to control people’s behaviour.
This set me wondering whether there was any connection between the way people respond to the rules of the market (in relation to how hard they work) and they way they respond to rules intended to govern their behaviour. In other words, if market rules cause people to be less generous with their work than they are when not bound by a framework of rules, is it possible that they might also behave better when there are fewer rules telling them what to do?
According to this theory, people dropped less litter fifteen years ago because they felt more personally responsible for their actions, but now they are so constrained by rules and regulations generally that they are less concerned by personal responsibility and more concerned by what they can get away with. And since dropping litter is easy to get away with, they are doing it more than they once were.
It would be fascinating to know whether any behavioural research work has been done to test this. Maybe an experiment could be constructed that would shed light on what is, politically speaking, an important question.
