Recent coverage of Liam Donaldson’s proposals for a minimum price for alcohol had ministers in a flat spin, simultaneously attracted to the idea of yet more regulation to control a social problem and appalled at the thought of artificially increasing the price of a drink in the middle of a recession.
In the end the recession won, hands down. Perhaps the government thinks that people need a drink to help them get through it. Gordon Brown said:
“We do not want the responsible, sensible majority of moderate drinkers to have to pay more or suffer as a result of the excesses of a small minority.”
James Purnell, the work and pensions secretary, was even more emphatic: “We want to focus on the irresponsible minority rather than … punishing everyone equally. … we are very clear we don’t want to punish the majority for the sins of the minority. …we are saying we have no intention of going ahead with something that would punish the responsible majority.”
Let’s not argue with that principle. What is interesting, however, is how novel it is in the New Labour era, which has seen an unprecedented tide of regulation sweep up upon the shores of an already over-regulated society. If you think about it, most regulation punishes the responsible majority for the sins of an “irresponsible” minority, banning activities that are fine so long as they are carried out in a responsible way.
Competent DIY-ers have to get building regulations approval for trivial works because incompetent ones might do something dangerous; farmers may not feed food waste to their pigs because it has happened that restaurant food waste was found to contain illegally sourced and contaminated meat; un-wed fathers may not obtain a passport for their own child because it happens very occasionally that they run off with them; the terminally ill may not take cannabis even though it helps to relieve their pain: in all these diverse cases and hundreds of others normal behaviour is forbidden because of the risk of aberration. The responsible majority cannot do what is normal and right because in a few instances wrong will be done.
Leave apart the fact that in many cases the wrong’uns will find a way to dodge the rules, so it is only the law-abiding who are forced to accept the inconvenience of them, it is a terrible comment upon society that normality should be so constrained. And woe betide the “normal” if their brand of normality should happen to include “innocent error”, or doing something that they shouldn’t, by mistake.
A story in the Totnes Times this week (only in print form at present) recounts the sad experience of a 20 year old lad living alone with his mother (the father died recently) who, when the dustmen failed to take all their rubbish, took the remaining black bags to a nearby recycling centre and left them stacked to one side. His mum was away and he didn’t know what to do for the best. Despite co-operating fully with the authorities when they came to enquire, he ended up with a fly-tipping conviction, a criminal record (DNA swabs, fingerprints and all the rest) and a substantial fine.
Now the law against fly-tipping, like the law against so many things, is intended (one hopes) to constrain people who behave with a callous disregard for other people and the environment – people who are exploitative of the difficulty society has in controlling those of malevolent intent. It has become so easy to “get away” with wrong-doing that society has reacted by making sanctions more and more severe for those who are caught.
But what happens when the ones who are caught are guilty of nothing more grievous that innocent error – unintended wrong-doing with no attempt at dissimulation and a willingness both to learn from the mistake made and to make amends?
It very much looks as if the criminal justice system is rapidly losing the capacity to discriminate in such cases, and that those guilty of innocent error are also “suffering as a result of the excesses of a small minority” – the small minority of serious malefactors against whom these laws were originally aimed.
