Reviewing, for this website, twenty years of writing and talking about what is wrong with the UK economy – and, increasingly, with economies across the “developed” or “western” world – it is clear that the problem is not that of attracting an audience.
My own audience may have been small, but many with far larger audiences have failed to make a significant impact. Nearly 40 years after the founding of the New Economics Foundation we are heading into a general election with both main parties and nearly all the smaller ones still fixated on completely bogus principles of “sound money”.
These principles state, for example, that it’s quite alright for a foreign-based private equity fund to “invest” (often with borrowed money) in UK public services such as care homes, prisons, nursery education, health provision, energy infrastructure, water, etc., etc., but it’s not alright for the government to invest the money itself.
And this despite the fact that those commercial investors are looking to make a profit that they will take with them, whereas if the government were to invest it could use that profit to enhance the public good. In practice (and in theory, too) that so-called foreign investment is a form of borrowing that will have to be paid back.
It also just happens to be borrowing on worse terms that the government would get if it borrowed the money directly. In the interests of keeping this borrowing “off the books” the government is shooting itself – and the rest of us – in the collective foot.
This is complicated stuff, not easy to explain. Four paragraphs in, and, if you are still with me at all, you may well be mightily confused. Even with twenty paragraphs there would still be a problem, because the neoliberal concept of sound money – the Thatcherite idea that a national economy works like a household – is firmly entrenched in mainstream economic and political discourse and incredibly hard to shift.
People willing to read long, reasoned, wordy arguments have mostly already made up their minds. People such as politicians, for whom the simplicity of a message is far more important that its truth, don’t want to engage with complexity and are terrified of departing from that mainstream discourse for fear of frightening the electorate.
The fact remains, however, that the UK is the sixth richest country in the world and pretty much everything in the domain of public service is broken. Meanwhile, millions of children live in poverty and people with quite respectable jobs are dependent upon food banks to ensure their families’ survival.
People know that the economic system is bust – but they don’t know why and they probably think that “bust” is normal. So it’s no use telling them why: people are increasingly immune to being “told”, and there is always someone ready with a counter argument that may be more forceful, if less true.
The solution, it seems to me, is to challenge that “normal” in ways that empower people to ask the important questions for themselves. This means finding innovative ways of shaping information that will overcome that “information immunity” and get people talking.
Just as artists, writers, musicians, poets and film-makers have brought the climate emergency to wider attention by weaving it into their work, the time has come to embrace economic change as a cultural imperative – an existential question that happens also to be linked closely to the environmental impacts of economic activity.
How to embed economic change into cultural life? That is the question I’ve been working with. I will keep you updated!

