Nearly half a century ago, the headmaster of a mid-rank independent school awoke to find that he had something akin to a riot on his hands. The subject of the protest was the military cadet training that pupils were obliged to undertake; the occasion was the night before the annual inspection by some distinguished military bod and the protest took the form of dumping most of the uniforms and other military paraphernalia in the school swimming bath.
The headmaster was a firm disciplinarian of unyielding mien – no shrinking violet, he – but also an intelligent and perceptive man. He swiftly rounded up the protest’s ringleaders and struck a deal. If the damage could be rectified, and the inspection go ahead, then he would talk. And so it was; the inspection went off successfully and after a decent interval a range of alternative activities was introduced for those pupils not attracted to quasi-military training.
In the aftermath of the recent riots, the government might well learn something from that venerable beak. Protest, even destructive and acquisitive protest, is rarely mindless; it is likely to have a purpose if only someone can be troubled to find out what it us. Finding out may not be simple, and may take time, but the task of healing the palpable damage is made simpler or more difficult by the quality of the reaction in the immediate aftermath.
Many of the people who got caught up in the criminal activity of the last few days may not have had more than the most superficial and momentary criminal intent. To treat and punish them as regular criminals, particularly with the harsh sentences that the magistrates courts have been dishing out in the past few days, dramatically increases the cost to society both in the short term and the more distant future. These people’s job and life prospects have now been severely blighted, and society will be paying the related financial and social cost of this for years to come. For those in receipt of the harsh sentences (and their friends and families), trust in authority to behave wisely and mercifully is progressively worsened; willingness to own up and try to remedy the damage done is devalued. Why would anyone take the risk?
More important still – the opportunity for a social healing has been gratuitously wasted. People have been encouraged to report their neighbours, friends and family members, and in some cases are doing so. Many more will not, except out of spite or enmity. Neither attitude is wholesome; a much more powerful and effective approach would be to offer a criminal amnesty to anybody who gives themselves up, or whose parent brings them in. They should return or pay for what they have stolen and pitch in to the clear-up operation that these communities need.
Forgiveness is a powerful tool, for it returns to the community the authority to take care of its own redemption. Instead of living in fear for their children, parents are empowered to liberate them from the threat of prosecution by showing them the right thing to do. At present, once young people get into the hands of the police, parents can do nothing to protect them; it is scarcely surprising that children in these circumstances no longer look to their parents as the authority figures that once they were.
An amnesty must be carefully handled, to be sure. Some people will abuse it, but society has a sorry record of denying itself good, promising, restorative outcomes for fear that a minority will, somehow, “get away with it”. It must be far more valuable to keep the first-time (and, hopefully, last-time) offenders onside for society that to prevent a few of the less-than-truly-repentant slipping through the justice net.
Other benefits: a big saving in police time and resources; a far higher clear-up rate for offences and the opportunity to focus efforts on the most marginalised people – those for whom the sustained intervention of police and social services can really make a difference, both to their own and other people’s lives.
No-brainer, anyone?
