Volcanic eruptions

General election campaigns are not the best moments to be touting new political ideas. Not big ideas, anyway; there are, of course, loads of so-called new ideas in the form of policy initiatives designed to please the crowd, some collected together under “big idea” umbrellas such as the conservatives Big Society, which is worthy it itself but lacks a credible philosophical context – which is another way of saying that if the underlying Conservative policy-set is not designed to reduce the extreme disparity between rich and poor that lies at the heart of Britain’s socio-economic malaise, then chucking a few crumbs in the direction of the third sector is not going to make much difference.

No, election campaigns are about not frightening the horses, which means making all your policies sound reasonable and moderate and middle of the road. That’s what did the trick for New Labour in 1997 and it is what is sustaining the Liberal Democrats in the aftermath of the Clegg phenomenon. The Lib Dems won’t get rid of Trident but will “strive for global nuclear disarmament, showing leadership by committing not to replace the Trident nuclear weapons system on a like-for-like basis“. That sounds much better. As for illegal immigrants, don’t even go there. The Lib Dem “amnesty” is so hedged about with conditions that it is doubtful if more than a handful of those forced into obscurity and exploitation under the current policies will get to see the light and breathe the air of real freedom.

What is new, however, in this election, is the almost palpable desire for an outcome that is different, even if people don’t necessarily know, and certainly don’t agree, about what different means. The Liberal Democrats, fronted by their media friendly leader, provide the straightest line in this direction. A “balanced parliament” may well have unpredictable and, quite likely, unintended consequences, but at least it will call a halt to the Thatcher-Blair project to control what everybody does, all the time, with an endless succession of new laws and regulations. It will, in summary, bring forth a government that is less powerful and more accountable. That, at least, is the hope.

To get to this point, however, has required voters to move away from the conventional wisdom that a Lib Dem vote is “wasted” – that it is only worth voting for an outfit that could actually form the next government. The transitional moment is said to have come in the first of the televised party leader debates, last Thursday, when Nick Clegg out-performed his rivals convincingly enough to give his party the momentum that it has so long lacked.

I wonder, however, whether the true moment of transition did not come on the previous day, when the Eyjafjallajökull volcano in Iceland blew its top. By bringing air traffic to a juddering halt in the middle of a holiday season, with knock-on effects for schools, businesses and government departments whose staff were left stranded around the world, the volcano demonstrated that dramatic change could happen and yet things still be OK.

People rallied round to cover for their absent colleagues, many of whom made adventurous overland journeys from countries that turned out to be quite a long way away. The mood was more excitement than despondency, with which, no doubt, the sunshine helped, especially for those living under flight paths who ventured into their gardens to make the most of the unexpected calm. What was missing, apart from in the boardrooms of the airlines which were losing money, was fear – fear of the unusual, the unexpected and the unpredictable, the pervasive and corroding emotion which governments traditionally mobilise to keep their peoples in line.

Could Iceland’s great volcano be the pre-cursor to a similarly seismic shift in British politics on 6 May? Are Britain’s electors at last ready to allow their desire for change to overcome their fear of uncertainty and, if so, to what extent is it the volcano and its aftermath that have shown them the way?