Family events caused an abrupt cessation in blog posts last Spring. By the time I came to pick it up again after a couple of months, my thinking had moved on to the point where I could see that the real need was for a coherent, comprehensive statement of Human Politics as a joined-up system of political thought. So I’ve been working hard on that, and plan to publish Human Politics: How democracy is failing in the West, and what to do about it in doue course. I will probably use Print on Demand as a publishing technology, although am open to alternative ideas about this.
Any comments I might have made last summer and autumn about the turn of political events were, however, conveniently made for me by the events themselves. If anyone was in any doubt about the inadequacy of rules and regulations as a framework for human behaviour they needed to look no further than the spectacle of our elected representatives queuing up to defend their indefensible behaviour in the matter of parliamentary expenses with the excuse that “it was all within the rules”. If even a political system was morally bankrupt, this is it.
Three other cases that hit the headlines made similar points. Attorney General Lady Scotland received a substantial fine from the Border Agency for a purely technical breach of draconian rules that she herself argued for in parliament. On any moral or even practical basis she’d done nothing wrong, but she had to pay up, all the same. Meanwhile, two policewomen who were child-minding for each other had to cease the arrangement when told by Ofsted that the exchange constituted remuneration and they would have to be registered and inspected. More recently, a man nearly got sent to prison for possession of a firearm, when he found a shotgun in his garden and took it to the police station. The facts in this last case were certainly a bit obscure, but it highlighted an important point about how strict liability (and minimum sentences) in criminal cases can punish behaviour that the circumstances might show to be reasonable and normal.
