Good and bad regulation

I missed this piece about the Manchester session of the Convention on modern Liberty and was glad to find it when trying to locate this item about the forthcoming UN declaration on drugs strategy. This declaration, we are told, is likely to commit the UN to another ten years of failure it its approach to recreational and addictive drugs.

The issues raised at Manchester relating to those “uncomfortable” freedoms in areas such as drugs and sexuality tend to give rise to a debate about the limits of freedom – a debate not about whether there should be regulation but about where the line should be drawn. Such discussions may be intellectually stimulating but are often inconclusive, and it is the lack of general agreement that allows a government to draw its politically expedient and often quite unnecessarily restrictive lines in the sand.

To make progress, the debate really needs to start from the other end. What happens when there is no regulation? To put that another way – to what extent would it affect people’s self-regulation if there was no external regulation, or are we now so habituated to external regulation that we have lost the capacity to regulate ourselves?

This leads to an interesting observation. Clearly, when there is no regulation, bad things happen. Equally clearly, when there is tight regulation, bad things happen. But does the fact that we have tight regulation make us feel better about the bad things that happen because we feel that we are trying to do something about it? Maybe that is part of the problem.

In the case of drugs, for example, the global disaster that is the illegal drugs market could scarcely be much worse if the trade were legal. The benefit of taking the crime out of it would probably offset the harm of any increase in consumption.

It would also allow “good” regulation to enter into the equation. Good regulation regulates what people cannot regulate for themselves – the quality of the product, for example, something impossible to control in an illegal market but which alone has big implications for drug users’ health. Good regulation also provides opportunities for education, like the health warnings that appear on packets of cigarettes.

The quality of good regulation is that it empowers people in relation to much bigger and more powerful entities (for example manufacturers), with whom they cannot otherwise hope to have an equal relationship. The quality of bad regulation is that it stops people from exercising their human judgement, and may cause them to lose the habit of acting well.

However much regulation we have, of either sort, bad stuff will still happen. But we urgently need a period of cold turkey, to take a break from our regulation addiction and find out what happens when people are empowered to make informed choices for themselves.