The Convention on Modern Liberty lived up to expectation and more – a very well organised and inspiring event with particular richness in the group sessions. There were many references to the human aspect of politics and the need to create a politics based on human relations. Philip Pullman’s reference to courage, modesty, honour and delight as the four essentials in our political discourse got the tone exactly right.
Even so there was something missing – at least from the plenary sessions. Maybe it was to be found in some of the group sessions that I couldn’t attend. This morning’s editorial in the Guardian said the convention…
…should focus on two destructive and deeply illiberal trends … The first is the legislative reflex that, as Sir Ken Macdonald, the former director of public prosecutions, recently put it, has turned the criminal justice system into an auction of fake toughness, putting politics before making Britain a safer place or respecting our traditions. The second is the trend towards routine intrusive state surveillance…
The second aspect was there in spades, with many, many references to data issues, ID cards, etc. There was also a lot said about the need for a written constitution. But on the first aspect the convention was more coy. There were references, of course, but I tried to pursue this point a little further during the final, after-hours, plenary, when I asked where, in this debate on liberty, were fox hunting, speed cameras and the question of the legalisation of drugs? Were these issues too controversial, I opined, for a meeting that had spend much of the day agreeing with itself?
I said something else, too. I drew attention to the relatively recent new law on causing death by careless driving, a law which criminalises and sends to prison people who have accidents that may be caused by momentary inattention. I ought to make it clear that so far in my driving career I’ve never encountered anything worse that a modest speeding ticket, so I’m not grinding a personal axe here. The point is (and this I didn’t have time to get across in my question) that there are probably thousands – probably millions – of momentary inattentions on our roads every day. Almost all of these go unnoticed, with a small proportion coming to the attention of enforcement officers and some – a minute proportion – ending in serious injury or fatality. To send someone to prison for a minor lapse that they did not intend makes them the victim of a lottery and is, I would contend, a example of precisely the “fake toughness, putting politics before making Britain a safer place,” of which the Guardian complained. The consequences of the act, however, tragic, do not make the gravity of the offence, nor does the punishment prevent it.
That sort of thing is not easy to hear for everyone, and Billy wasn’t having any of it. It seemed that so far as he was concerned, if you’d killed someone your human rights were for the birds. If you’ve never received a put-down from Billy Bragg before then here’s a piece of advice for when it happens. Make sure you’ve got the microphone, or at least a microphone. If he’s got one and you haven’t then you haven’t a prayer!
To be fair, it was five to seven in the evening and the convention was due to end on the hour, so it was a reasonable moment for Henry Porter to say let’s not have a debate on driving. A reasonable moment to say it, but not, as I’m sure he will agree, a reasonable thing to say in the absolute. Because if this debate on liberty is to get beyond the “chattering classes” it has to go to where people really are, and the injustices most people are aware of experiencing in their daily lives are not, in fact, related to id cards or computer data but to uncomfortable and ethically messy real things like speed cameras, driving offences, drugs offences, or, in the case of one person at the convention who struggled to get a hearing, having your children taken into care for what may or may not have been a good reason.
Still, it was a great day, even if it has left a lot of unfinished business. And what made it for me was the kindness of the woman who came up to me as I was leaving to say how rude she felt that Billy had been in his reply to me, and how he’d totally missed the point of what I was saying. I asked her about her interest in the convention and she gave me her blog address, so now I can say “Thank you, Janet”, for a practical demonstration of what we mean when we say that politics is an exercise in unmediated human interaction. Of courage, modesty, honour and delight all four were present in her taking the trouble to approach me.
