The spectacle of government and former government members complaining about Sir Fred Goodwin’s pension arrangements is unedifying, to say the least. Colossal rewards for executives and a widening of the pay gap between the best and worst paid in the workforce has been a consistent feature of the economic structure of the country for the whole of this government’s term and even longer than that. The relationship between success and reward has frequently been tenuous: after all, nobody seemed to begrudge the bankers that stratospheric remuneration until recently, even though the seeds of the current failures and losses were planted years ago.
From a Human Politics perspective, however, there is an important point behind all this grotesque political opportunism. For people to relate to each other freely on a human level, there needs to be an equality that they both recognise. For most of Sir Fred’s business customers at RBS, their business going bust would leave them only with what the bankruptcy arrangements allow them to get by. But the corporate structure of limited liability and the limited liability of directors for the consequences of their decisions means that company directors often do not share the financial struggles that follow from business failure.
Company law creates a privileged class of individual with a degree of immunity from the consequences of their own actions, and this alone distorts the network of free relationships that is required if a society is to flourish in freedom. Personally I wouldn’t mind seeing Sir Fred hang on to his pension pot if it causes us to remember that in politics it’s no good just reacting to the things that happen that one doesn’t like. Moral reaction is too late: a moral and just society needs thinking out in advance.
